I never deny my love affair with peppermint flavored things, but during the month of December, I let my peppermint flag fly high. Literally. To mark the occasion, I decided to combine this reader favorite recipe with the holiday season to create peppermint eggnog milkshake shots that are perfectly petit enough to fit any party… unless the big and tall section is more your style, in which case you can turn this into a punch bowl recipe.
Ingredients:
- Peppermint ice cream
- Peppermint white chocolate bark
- Crushed peppermint
- Eggnog
- Sugar water
Blend together 2 parts peppermint ice cream to one part eggnog. Rim the glasses with with crushed peppermint by dabbing them with sugar water and dipping them in peppermint. Fill your glasses with the milkshake mixture and place them in the freezer until you’re ready to serve. Break the peppermint bark into halves and place them on top just before serving.

















Ashley, you always amaze me with your talent…your food/drink presentation is as wonderful as your recipes!
I don’t like eggnog but this is so pretty that I’m sure I couldn’t resist to try it if offered like this ;)
These would be absolutely perfect for this hot summery weather here in Sydney! Love it!
Ahh I so wanna try these! Where do you get your adorable striped straws? I wanna set up a drink tray for my New Year’s Eve party!
OOO these looks great! I love peppermint :)
Aww crap, these look delicious!
Company milkshakes for lunch ;)
[...] Thanks Sugar & Cloth [...]
I’ve never been a fan of eggnog, but I may need to try this—it looks so yummy!
You totally should!
Honestly!!! These are too die for! I am this close to licking my computer screen…
Haha, I just love you!
this is so darn adorable! i love this idea for upcoming holiday parties. i must post this on my blog. from one blogger to another, i just want to say i’m fascinated with your style and creativity. keep up the great work! :)
Oh man, thank you! You just made my day!
I have to make this!! It looks beautiful and must taste delicious!! =)
Ergo-Blog
OMT! I want this NOW! Too bad Germans are not at all into peppermint and therefore I won’t be able to buy any peppermint ice cream or peppermint chocolate! And there is also no Eggnogg :(
You can come visit and I’ll introduce you to the awesomeness ;)
I LOVE the idea of pepperminting up some eggnog! Yum!
I found your recipe through Pinterest. I’m not a huge eggnog fan, but the photo was so nicely styled that I was intrigued. I made these for a girl’s lunch yesterday and they were a huge hit! One of my girlfriend’s even asked where I found the recipe. I’m happy to have found your blog-thank you for the very delicious and festive recipe!
[...] Eggnog Milkshake Shots How cute do these little dessert shots look from Sugar & Cloth? Peppermint ice cream mixed with eggnog and a peppermint sugar rimmed glass. Stripped straws and a [...]
[...] Peppermint eggnog [...]
[...] Get the recipe here. [...]
[...] Eggnog Milkshake Shots via Sugar and Cloth 2. Layered Peppermint Cheesecake via myrecipes 3. Peppermint Macarons via anna and blue [...]
To turn these into a cocktail sort, would you add vodka or rum?
I would think a liqueur would be best, but I’m not the cocktail sort, so I’m probably not the best to ask :)
[...] 2. Peppermint Eggnog Milkshake Shots [...]
[...] Recipe Here [...]
[...] recipe source: sugar and cloth [...]