This Spicy Skinny Margarita recipe is a low-calorie version of the well-loved jalapeño margarita cocktail. It only requires a few ingredients, and of course, the best tequila!
It’s been a while since we shared a classic cocktail recipe around here! Fear not, this Spicy Skinny Margarita recipe should reaffirm our dedication to the craft of cocktails, with or without Cinco de Mayo.
We’re whipping up the deliciousness that is this Spicy Skinny Margarita for two reasons. Number one being swimsuit season is upon us. (Please send help.) And number two because there is nothing better than sips with a little kick!
Okay okay, the real reason we prefer a spicy margarita recipe is simply because it keeps us sipping instead of totally chug my glass. At least we’re honest, right?
In our defense, we don’t drink any type of sodas (usually only water, coffee, green juices,…and cocktails of course). So they’re our drink treat of choice. Plus, you can easily customize this into a mocktail too!
If you’re not a big fan of spicy drinks, you can nix the jalapeno and rock the rest of the recipe! It will run you about 100 calories per servings if you’re using stevia or light agave nectar instead of simple syrup.
I love the stevia option for a naturally sweetened, low carb drink.
What is a Skinny Margarita?
In case you’re trying to figure out why in the world you would change a good thing (aka a classic margarita recipe), here are a few reasons why…
Not everyone handles the sugar that sometimes comes along with a frozen margarita and even some of the top-shelf margaritas on the rocks.
If you’re prone to headaches or easy hangovers, this is a much more natural, healthy cocktail option since it’s primarily freshly squeezed lime juice and fresh orange juice over ice cubes.
It probably goes without saying, but these will also run you a fraction of the calories too! It’s definitely a diet-friendly option if you’re looking to indulge without the extra calorie intake.
Of course, you don’t HAVE to give up your favorite orange liqueur or triple sec if you really want it! You can just scale back on the amount you add to your cocktail shaker since the stevia will balance the flavor.
How to Garnish a Skinny Spicy Margarita
It’s all in the details, right?! When it comes to garnishing your skinny margarita, you can keep things healthy by using pink Himalayan salt and a lime wedge in lieu of a traditional salted rim.
All you have to do is pour a bit of salt on a plate, then run a lime wedge around the rim of your glass and dip in the salt.
You’ll pour your cocktail straight into the garnished glass, and serve with an extra lime wedge, and in this glass, a slice of jalapeno.
What’s the Best Tequila for Margaritas?
Regardless of whether you’re making a classic margarita, a spicy skinny margarita, or a frozen margarita mix, you can never go wrong with choosing the best quality tequila.
That also doesn’t exactly mean this is going to be a Patron margarita either. We’re a big fan of silver tequilas for their smoothness. We used it to create our festive Easter Margarita also.
If you’re looking for the best tequila on a budget, you should try out Jose Cuervo’s Tradicional Plata Silver Tequila or Espolon Silver Tequila.
An Easy Skinny Margarita Pitcher Recipe
When you’re in the middle of hosting a party, it’s not always ideal to make a single cocktail at a time…obviously!
To make this into the best margarita recipe for a group, try these adjustments — 4.5 cups of silver tequila, 2 cups of light orange juice, 1 cup of freshly squeezed lime juice, and Stevia to sweeten.
You can mix all of the ingredients in a pitcher in the refrigerator until ready to serve. It’s best to have a separate ice bucket for guests to pour a drink themselves as they’re ready so that the pitcher doesn’t get watered down.
Another recipe you might want to try for a big crowd is this Mojito Pitcher Recipe.
Anyone else there that loves a spicy cocktail? It definitely makes me take my time during a happy hour without the sugar guilt. A win, win in my book.
Skinny Spicy Margarita Recipe
- 1 1/2 oz silver tequila
- 1 oz light orange juice
- 1 1/2 oz fresh lime juice
- 1 dash light agave nectar or stevia add more or less for desired taste
- 2 slice jalapeno seeded
- Pink himalayan salt optional for rimming
- 4.5 cups of silver tequila
- 2 cups of light orange juice
- 1 cup of freshly squeezed lime juice
- Stevia to sweeten
- Combine the lime juice, orange juice, your choice of light sweetener, and silver tequila in a cocktail shaker and mix.
- You can also add a jalapeno slice to the shaker to add a little extra kick before you strain and pour into glasses, too.
- Strain the mixture over ice after rimming your glass with salt (optional), then add two slices of jalapeno and a lime wedge for garnishing.
Easy Cocktail Recipes
Rose Cocktails with Flower Sprinkles
This Rose cocktail is as pretty as it is easy to make...
24 Carrot Cocktail Recipe
A carrot cocktail recipe seems a bit out there, but this one it worth a try!...
Ice Sphere Cocktail
I mean, if you can break your cocktail with a hammer, it's sure to be a hit!...
Spring Fling Cocktail Recipe
This Spring Fling cocktail goes down easy and is just as easy to make...
Sherry Berry Cocktail Recipe
This sherry berry cocktail recipe is always a crowd pleaser...
Dark & Stormy Cocktail Recipe
A classic, easy dark and stormy cocktail recipe...
Esmeralda Fizz Cocktail recipe
This esmeralda fizz cocktail is the perfect Palm Springs inspired drink...
Corpse Reviver Cocktail Recipe
A spooky and delicious corpse reviver cocktail...
Whiskey Dreamsicle Cocktail
If you love dreamsicles and whiskey, this cocktail recipe is for you!...
Sparkling Pimm's Cup Cocktail
A classic pimm's cup cocktail recipe is always good to have on hand...
Glossary of Macarons Cocktail
This one is inspired by our love of macarons...
Creamy Birthday Cake Cocktail
You can have your cake and eat it too with this creamy birthday cake cocktail recipe...
Coffee Old Fashioned Cocktail Recipe
While not your typical combination, this coffee old fashioned cocktail recipe is super unique...
3 Sparkling Ice Cream Cocktail Recipes
You had me at ice cream with this sparkling ice cream cocktail recipe...
Lucky Coconut Mint Chip Cocktail Recipe
Are you feeling lucky?! Here's a coconut mint chip cocktail to try out...
Edible Flower Rainbow Sour Cocktail Recipe
Edible flowers and rainbows, oh my! Try this rainbow sour for a colorful drink...Wh
Detoxing Activated Charcoal Cocktail Recipe
Black isn't your typical cocktail color, but it's definitely a conversation starter with this detoxing activated charcoal cocktail!
Peach and Blackberry Bramble Cocktail Recipe
This peach and blackberry bramble is the perfect fall cocktail pairing...
Lavender Grapefruit Gin Buck Cocktail
A gin buck cocktail? Yes, please!...
Blood Orange & Rose Creamsicle Cocktail
Back at it with the creamsicle cocktail and this time it's got a blood orange and rose combination...
Immunity Boosting Citrus Gin Punch Cocktail
In case you're wondering how a cocktail is immune boosting, click through to see the recipe!...
Sparkling Strawberry Hibiscus Cooler Cocktail Recipe
A hibiscus cooler recipe?! Say no more...
Apple Brandy Allspice Fizz Thanksgiving Cocktail Recipe
A beautiful AND easy cocktail recipe to whip up for Thanksgiving this year...
Sips For Summer: Slushy Coconut Mint Margarita Cocktail
A slushy coconut mint margarita recipe for the win...
10 thoughts on “Spicy Skinny Margarita Recipe”
Oh my God! Spicy recipe! Love it!
haha, I love my drinks with a little kick :)
These look so good! Xo
Thanks, Carrie! xo
So if I drink enough of these I’ll be skinny. Right? ;)
They are BEAUTIFUL and sound sooo delicious.
hahaha! So true!
Yes! I’m all about a spicy margarita and even better if it’s skinny.
Right?! I was definitely taste testing the props..
Oooh, spicy! Who knew a margarita could be so pretty, too?
Thanks, Julie! xo