26 Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts Your Sweetheart Actually Wants

Roses are red, violets are blue, personalized gifts say “I love you”! Discover our cupid approved personalized Valentine’s Day gifts that will leave your sweetheart swooning.

Personalized Valentines Day Gifts

Valentine’s Day is the perfect occasion to celebrate love in its most personalized form. Unlike birthday gifts, Vday gifts are all about LOVE! A personalized gift adds an extra touch of love and thoughtfulness that really amps up all the warm fuzzy feels.

From custom-made  jewelry, albums and engraved perfumes, a personalized gift speaks volumes. It not only showcases the effort taken to create something so unique, but it also highlights all your shared memories and intimate connection. 

These are the gifts that become meaningful treasures, holding sentimental value that bypass material worth. Personalized gifts remind us that love is not just in grand gestures but also in the intricate details that are crafted with love and care. Which is what makes Valentine’s Day a truly memorable and heartwarming celebration.

How to Pick Personalized Valentine Gifts that Don’t Suck

  • Know what they love: Pick something personalized that vibes with your partner’s  interests. If they’re into cozy stuff, a custom blanket or pillow would be perfect. If they’re more into things that sparkle, consider some personalized jewelry. Knowing what they’re into helps you pick the perfect custom valentine gifts.
  • Make it a trip down memory lane: Go for something that brings back special shared memories. It could be a scrapbook, a custom map, or a photo collage. Reminding them of the good times makes for the best gift ideas.
  • Don’t skimp on quality: Sure, personalization is key, but don’t go for something that falls apart after a week. Aim for a good balance between unique and well-made. Whether it’s a custom mug or a piece of art, a sturdy quality custom Valentine’s gifts shows you care about the long run.

So this year we’re skipping the traditional chocolates and flowers, and instead are opting for something truly memorable – unique valentine gifts that are personalized to your special person that will leave a lasting impression. We guarantee it! 

Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts 

1 – Date Night In

Date Night In: An Activity Journal for Couples

Some of the best date nights are the ones spent at home cuddled up together on the couch streaming a movie and ordering takeout. Sometimes it’s fun to try something new and that is when this Date Night In Journal comes in. 

No matter how long you’ve been in your relationship, there is something special for you to do together. Walk down memory lane, learn more about the one you love and deepen your connection all from the comfort of your own home.

2 – Personalized Boxers

Personalized Boxers Briefs with Picture, Custom Face Underwear with Your Name, Cotton Briefs with Photo Funny Boxer Shorts Underpants Briefs Custom Gifts for Men Husband Father Boyfriend Him - M

Wearing your sweetheart’s face on boxers? It’s like having your heart on your sleeve… or, uh, somewhere else! These personalized boxers are the ultimate “I’ve got you covered” gift. Did you know fashion could be this personal? Let’s just hope these boxers don’t start giving relationship advice!

3 – Custom Spotify Album Cover

Custom Spotify Album Cover, Custom Portrait Cover With Your Song, Wedding Anniversary Gifts, Gifts for Couples, Digital Download, Gift Idea for personalized Valentine's Day gifts

personalized Spotify album cover is like creating a mixtape for the digital age! You can take “our song”  plus a special photo of you and your sweetie and make it a special keepsake that can be hung in your home or office so that each time you pass it you can think of your love.

4 – Spilling The Tinder Tea

I'm So Glad We Swiped Right Mug, Personalized Couples Coffee Mugs, Custom Valentine's Day Gift, Gift for Her, Gift for Him, Couples Gift for personalized Valentines gifts

It’s no secret that lots of couples meet online these days. What better way to honor where your humble beginnings, then with these matching swipe right mugs. The Tinder Tea was clearly hot because it brought you to each other.

5 – Initial Heart Custom Sweatshirts

Initial Heart Custom Embroidered Crewneck // Personalized Couple Hoodies // Bridge // Bridesmaid // Personalized Gift // Anniversary Date

Everyone loves a cozy sweatshirt and matching sweatshirts are the “we’re so cute it should be illegal” kind of fashion statement that we are here for.

I mean, who needs a heart emoji when you can have it stitched on your chest? These initial heart custom embroidered sweatshirts are like shouting to the world, “Hey, we’re a team, and we’ve got our own matching uniform!” 

6 – Wooden Photo Box

Pull Out Photo Album, Valentines Memory Collection, Personalised Wooden Photo Frame, Gift for Him, Trinket Wooden Box, First Christmas Gift

“We keep this love in a photograph. We made these memories for ourselves”. What better way to commemorate your love and all your special memories then to create a custom pull out photo album.

Kept neatly in a personalized wooden box, it’s an extra special keepsake that freezes your favorite memories in time.

7 – Fingerprint Ring

Fingerprint Ring | Custom Fingerprint Band Ring | Thumb Ring | Dainty Ring | Engagement Ring | Promise Ring | Memorial Mother's Day Gift

This memorable gift gives a whole new spin to “putting a ring on it”. These custom fingerprint rings are an ultra unique gift that is all about connection. No two fingerprints are the same and there is something so intimate about wearing your love’s print on you at all times. 

8 – Ticket to Love Box

Personalized Ticket to Love Box

When it comes to wooing that special someone, this personalized gift box contains sweet ideas that go straight to the heart. Peruse 40 fabulous ticket ideas, and pick the 10 options you know your partner will love – ranging from “Free Back Rub” and “A Day of ‘Yes'” to more personal, private, clothing-optional adventures. 

9 – Love Is Art Kit 

Love Is Art Kit

This spicy personalized Valentines gift gives a whole new take to the term “art lover”. This highly personal painting is created in the bedroom if you catch our drift. Capture your passion, and celebrate your bond with boldly intimate art. We promise this sexy gift is one your partner won’t soon forget. 

10 – Personalized Resort Robe

Waffle Weave Resort Robe by Pattern Barn for personalized Valentines gifts

Bring the luxury spa vibe right to your sweetheart’s doorstep with a personalized resort robe! It’s the ultimate “treat yourself” gift idea but with a personal touch. 

Now they can lounge in style, feeling like they’re on a perpetual vacation. The best part is every time they slip it on, it’s like a warm hug from you. Just make sure they don’t start requesting room service at home!

11 – Personalized Vase

Personalized Vase for valentines gifts ideas

Who doesn’t love fresh flowers? Even better when your gorgeous blooms come in a special vase. A personalized vase is a great way to signify your love with initials or a meaningful date. 

Suddenly, it’s not just a vase but a reminder of your shared moments. Every time your love arranges flowers, it will be a reminder of your love.

12 – Personalized Heart Champagne Glasses

Personalized Champagne Glasses for personalized Valentine's Gifts

Nothing says “cheers to us” quite like heart champagne glasses. Toast to your love and your future with these personalized wine glasses. Take them out weekly and make your love (and a glass of bubbly) a priority! We suggest our Strawberry Bellini! 

13 – Monogrammed Corkcicle Cigar Glass

Monogrammed Corkcicle Cigar Glass

Personalized Valentine’s gifts can be known to be tacky, but we promise this one is nothing but classy! A monogrammed Corkcicle cigar glass is one classy move! Now, your cigar can enjoy its smoky moment with a touch of sophistication. 

It’s not just a glass. It’s a statement piece that adds a dash of swag to your smoke break. The only thing missing is a tiny monocle for your cigar to complete the dapper look! This also makes the perfect gift for a bourbon lover.

14 – Engraveable Cologne

Jo Malone Peony & Blush Suede Cologne

It is said that scent is the strongest tie to memory. Choosing an engravable cologne for your Valentine is like adding a personal note to the art of scent. Engrave with their name or your anniversary. Bonus because every time they spritz, not only will they smell incredible but it will be a fragrant reminder of your love. 

15 – What I Love About Us Book

Knock Knock What I Love about Us Fill in the Love Book Fill-in-the-Blank Gift Journal, 4.5 x 3.25-inches

Ok, hear us out. We know it sounds super cheesy, but there is no better time to up the cheese factor than on Valentine’s Day. Choosing a What I Love About Us book is like creating a personalized chronicle of your relationship journey.

It’s not just a book. It’s a thoughtful collection of the things that make your relationship uniquely special. From shared moments to individual quirks, it captures the essence of “us”.’ Then, in years to come flipping through its pages is a heartwarming experience, a reminder of the countless reasons why your connection is so special. 

16 – Letters To My Love

Letters to My Love: Write Now. Read Later. Treasure Forever. (Love Letters, Love and Romance Gifts, Letter Books)

That’s right not one but TWO cheesy books to ring in the day of love. We are telling you nothing is more special than your love put into words and written down.

It’s a tangible gift of emotion that we know your Valentine will love…even if they tell you what a cheeseball you are for gifting it to them. This Letters to My Love book features 12 romantic handwritten letters. It’s the gift that makes putting your love into words easy again. 

17 – Create Your Own Wheel Finder

Create Your Own Reel Viewer

Talk about a trip down memory lane. Who remembers these vintage wheel finders and how much fun they were to have as kids? Tap into their inner child as well as your love story by creating your own personalized wheel finder filled with cherished memories you have together. 

18 –  Letter Necklace 

Letter Necklace,Heart Letter Necklace , Custom Initial Necklace , Gold Custom Gift ,Christmas Gift for personalized valentines days gifts

We know about wearing your heart on your sleeve, but what about your love’s initials on your neck? This dainty letter necklace is stunningly beautiful and a unique way to share your bond. Every time your name necklace catches the light it can serve as a reminder of your love and special bond.

19 – Custom Name Bracelet

Custom Name Bracelet with Curb Chain - Personalized Name Jewelry - Birthday Gift for Her *NELLY BRACELET*

Opting for a custom name bracelet as a gift is like wrapping a little piece of personal connection around their wrist. It’s not just a piece of jewelry. It’s a wearable reminder of their unique identity. Engraving their name or a special word adds a touch of intimacy, turning a simple bracelet into a meaningful accessory.

20 – Custom Minifigures

Couples in love - Personalized LEGO figures / Create your own LEGO minifigures - the best Valentine’s day / anniversary gift for her & him

Choosing a custom LEGO mini-figure as a personalized gift is like turning playtime into a personal masterpiece. It’s not just a toy. It’s a tiny version of your love that you can display. 

It’s a creative and thoughtful way to capture your story in a small, blocky form. Plus, it’s a gift that unleashes the inner child in all of us, bringing a playful and nostalgic touch to your Valentine’s Day.

21 – Love Message Cookies

Love Message Shortbread Cookies

Sweets for your sweetie. The way to anyone’s heart is through their stomach, and these delicious love message cookies are the perfect personalized treat! Customize your message to your sweetie and make their afternoon coffee or tea extra sweet.

22 – Custom Map Keychain

Bronze Custom Map Heart Key Ring

A keychain may not sound romantic, but it’s the “key” to any traveler’s heart! Preserve memories of your most meaningful travels and preserve it in a beautiful bronze heart custom map keychain. 

23 – Love Pills

FUTUREPLUSX 100 Pcs Capsule Message in a Glass Bottle Love Pill Notes for Valentine's Day, Capsules Letters for Birthday Anniversary Mother's Day Thanksgiving Day Christmas Gift

What’s the saying? A love pill a day keeps the therapist away? We kid, of course. But how precious and thoughtful are these customized love pills? Write a little love letter, and roll up in these cute little pills so your sweetie can have a little pick me up when they are feeling down or they miss you! 

24 – Custom Portrait 

Custom Portrait Illustration, Wedding gift, Couple Portrait, Drawing From Photo, Best Friend gift, Line Drawing, Personalised Art Commission for personalized valentines day gifts

Having a custom art print commissioned is a timeless and classic gift that captures the essence of your love. Plus, it just sounds cool as heck and is possibly one of the more romantic wall art gifts you can give. This also makes for a unique anniversary gift.

25 — Personalized Scratch Away I Love You Card

Scratch Away I Love You Card - Top 10 Reasons Why I Love You - Valentines Day, Anniversary, Birthday, Wedding - 8.5"x11" - Personalized Card - Custom Love Card - Scratch Off Stickers - Gift For Kids, Husband, Wife (Red)

Express your love in a uniquely charming way scratch away “I Love You” greeting card. Customize it with 10 reasons why you’re head over heels, and then surprise your special someone with a delightful, interactive experience that reveals your heartfelt sentiments.

26 — Memory Keepsake Dish Set

Memory Keepsake Dish Set for personalized valentines gifts

We’ve saved the best for last in our humble opinion. These little dishes are tiny treasure chests, perfect for holding tokens of your love – a movie ticket, a shared keepsake, or a small note. 

It’s not just a set of dishes; it’s a thoughtful and practical way to infuse your space with reminders of your love story. Each dish carries a bit of your story, making it a sentimental and decorative addition to your home.

More Valentine’s Gift Ideas

For more romantic gift ideas, check out and shop some of our favorite gift roundups below — 

All Things Valentine’s Days

Please note that we may earn a commission for some of the above affiliate links. However, products featured are independently selected and personally well-loved by us!

2 thoughts on “26 Personalized Valentine’s Day Gifts Your Sweetheart Actually Wants”

  1. I want to get a custom portrait of my partner and I SO badly! I want to get it in an anime/cartoon design of one of the shows that we both love so it’s extra special, as that’s something that we’ve bonded over, plus we plan on putting up a lot of art that’s from the shows we’ve watched together too.

    Initial jewellery is also a lovely gift, I think. I saw my friend wearing one of her boyfriend’s first name and loved it, so I *subtly* hinted that I wanted one too, and my partner got me a necklace with the letter of his first name. I love it so much and it means a lot to me 🥰

    Reply
    • We think you need to leave this blog post open and out on your computer or your partner’s computer for your partner to see! ;)

      Reply

Leave a Comment